Avoiding Tree Damage During Construction
As cities and suburbs expand, wooded lands are being developed into commercial
and residential sites. Homes are constructed in the midst of trees to take
advantage of the aesthetic and environmental value of the wooded lots. Wooded
properties can be worth as much as 20 percent more than those without trees,
and people value the opportunity to live among trees.
Unfortunately, the processes involved with
construction can be deadly to nearby trees. Unless the damage is extreme, the
trees may not die immediately but could decline over several years. With this
delay in symptom development, you may not associate the loss of the tree with
It is possible to preserve trees on
building sites if the right measures are taken. The most important step is to
hire a professional arborist during the planning stage. An arborist can help
you decide which trees can be saved and can work with the builder to protect
the trees throughout each construction phase.
How Trees Are Damaged During Construction
Physical Injury to Trunk and Crown.
Construction equipment can injure the aboveground portion of a tree by breaking
branches, tearing the bark, and wounding the trunk. These injuries are
permanent and, if extensive, can be fatal.
Cutting of Roots.
The digging and trenching that are necessary to construct a house and install
underground utilities will likely sever a portion of the roots of many trees in
the area. It is easy to appreciate the potential for damage if you understand
where roots grow. The roots of a tree are found mostly in the upper 6 to 12
inches of the soil. In a mature tree, the roots extend far from the trunk. In
fact, roots typically are found growing a distance of one to three times the
height of the tree. The amount of damage a tree can suffer from root loss
depends, in part, on how close to the tree the cut is made. Severing one major
root can cause the loss of 5 to 20 percent of the root system.
Another problem that may result from root loss caused by digging and trenching
is that the potential for the trees to fall over is increased. The roots play a
critical role in anchoring a tree. If the major support roots are cut on one
side of a tree, the tree may fall or blow over.
Less damage is done to tree roots if utilities are tunneled under a tree rather
than across the roots.
An ideal soil for root growth and development is about 50 percent pore space.
These pores—the spaces between soil particles—are filled with water
and air. The heavy equipment used in construction com-pacts the soil and can
dramatically reduce the amount of pore space. This compaction not only inhibits
root growth and penetration but also decreases oxygen in the soil that is
essential to the growth and function of the roots.
Smothering Roots by Adding Soil.
Most people are surprised to learn that 90 percent of the fine roots that
absorb water and minerals are in the upper 6 to 12 inches of soil. Roots
require space, air, and water. Roots grow best where these requirements are
met, which is usually near the soil surface. Piling soil over the root system
or increasing the grade smothers the roots. It takes only a few inches of added
soil to kill a sensitive mature tree.
Exposure to the Elements.
Trees in a forest grow as a community, protecting each other from the elements.
The trees grow tall, with long, straight trunks and high canopies. Removing
neighboring trees or opening the shared canopies of trees during construction
exposes the remaining trees to sunlight and wind. The higher levels of sunlight
may cause sunscald on the trunks and branches. Also, the remaining trees are
more prone to breaking from wind or ice loading.
Hire a professional arborist in the early planning stage. Many of the trees on
your property may be saved if the proper steps are taken. Allow the arborist to
meet with you and your building contractor. Your arborist can assess the trees
on your property, determine which are healthy and structurally sound, and
suggest measures to preserve and protect them.
One of the first decisions is determining which trees are to be preserved and
which should be removed. You must consider the species, size, maturity,
location, and condition of each tree. The largest, most mature trees are not
always the best choices to preserve. Younger, more vigorous trees usually can
survive and adapt to the stresses of construction better. Try to maintain
diversity of species and ages. Your arborist can advise you about which trees
are more sensitive to compaction, grade changes, and root damage.
Your arborist and builder should work together in planning the construction.
The builder may need to be educated regarding the value of the trees on your
property and the importance of saving them. Few builders are aware of the way
trees' roots grow and what must be done to protect them.
Sometimes small changes in the placement or design of your house can make a
great difference in whether a critical tree will survive. An alternative plan
may be more friendly to the root system. For example, bridging over the roots
may substitute for a conventional walkway. Because trenching near a tree for
utility installation can be damaging, tunneling under the root system may be a
Because our ability to repair construction damage to trees is limited, it is
vital that trees be protected from injury. The single most important action you
can take is to set up construction fences around all of the trees that are to
remain. The fences should be placed as far out from the trunks of the trees as
possible. As a general guideline, allow 1 foot of space from the trunk for each
inch of trunk diameter. The intent is not merely to protect the aboveground
portions of the trees but also the root systems. Remember that the root systems
extend much farther than the drip lines of the trees.
Instruct construction personnel to keep the fenced area clear of building
materials, waste, and excess soil. No digging, trenching, or other soil
disturbance should be allowed in the fenced area.
Protective fences should be erected as far out from the trunks as possible in
order to protect the root system.
If at all possible, it is best to allow only one access route on and off the
property. All contractors must be instructed where they are permitted to drive
and park their vehicles. Often this same access drive can later serve as the
route for utility wires, water lines, or the driveway.
Specify storage areas for equipment, soil, and construction materials. Limit
areas for burning (if permitted), cement wash-out pits, and construction work
zones. These areas should be away from protected trees.
Get it in writing. All of the measures intended to protect your trees must be
written into the construction specifications. The written specifications should
detail exactly what can and cannot be done to and around the trees. Each
subcontractor must be made aware of the barriers, limitations, and specified
work zones. It is a good idea to post signs as a reminder.
Fines and penalties for violations should be built into the specifications. Not
too surprisingly, subcontractors are much more likely to adhere to the tree
preservation clauses if their profit is at stake. The severity of the fines
should be proportional to the potential damage to the trees and should increase
for multiple infractions.
Maintaining Good Communications
It is important to work together as a team. You may share clear objectives with
your arborist and your builder, but one subcontractor can destroy your prudent
efforts. Construction damage to trees is often irreversible.
Visit the site at least once a day if possible. Your vigilance will pay off as
workers learn to take your wishes seriously. Take photos at every stage of
construction. If any infraction of the specifications does occur, it will be
important to prove liability.
It is not unusual to go to great lengths to preserve trees during construction,
only to have them injured during landscaping. Installing irrigation systems and
rototilling planting beds are two ways the root systems of trees can be
damaged. Remember also that small increases in grade (as little as 2 to 6
inches) that place additional soil over the roots can be devastating to your
trees. Careful planning and communicating with landscape designers and
contractors is just as important as avoiding tree damage during construction.
Post-Construction Tree Maintenance
Your trees will require several years to adjust to the injury and environmental
changes that occur during construction. Stressed trees are more prone to health
problems such as disease and insect infestations. Talk to your arborist about
continued maintenance for your trees. Continue to monitor your trees, and have
them periodically evaluated for declining health or safety hazards.
Despite the best intentions and most stringent tree preservation
measures, your trees still might be injured from the construction process. Your
arborist can suggest remedial treatments to help reduce stress and improve the
growing conditions around your trees. Treatment
of Trees Damaged by Construction.